The appraisal came back below the contract price, or below the value your refinance was built on. The price you agreed to has not moved, but the loan is sized from the appraised value, so the difference has to come from somewhere: the seller, your cash, a request for a second look, a different plan, or the exit the contract gives you.
This post covers the three places a low appraisal bites, the options in each, the math behind every option, and how to choose between them. It is education, not legal, tax, or financial advice.
Why a low appraisal changes the deal
A lender sizes its loan from the value it will lend against. On a purchase, many lenders use the lower of the contract price and the appraised value; the rule is set by your lender, so confirm yours. On a refinance, the appraised value is the base. Either way, the loan is the lender's loan-to-value fraction of that base, and the shortfall between the value you planned on and the appraised value is the appraisal gap.
The gap reaches you in two ways. On a purchase, the loan falls by the loan-to-value share of the gap, so your cash to close rises by that share if the price stays put. And if you pay the contract price, you own the property for the whole gap more than the appraisal concluded it was worth. The worked example below shows both.
A low appraisal bites in three places:
- A financed purchase. The appraisal comes in below the contract price, and the lender funds less of the price than you planned.
- A refinance. The appraisal comes in below the value your plan assumed, so the new loan is smaller. In a BRRRR, that means less of your capital comes back out.
- Your resale to a financed buyer. On a flip or a novation, the buyer's lender appraises the house, and a low value leaves your buyer short of the price you agreed.
The options on a financed purchase
Six options apply, alone or in combination. Each one below states what it changes in the math.
Renegotiate the price
Ask the seller to lower the price to the appraised value, or toward it. If they agree, the price and the loan base match again, your cash to close falls, and you start with no gap between price and value. The math: cash to close = the new price − the loan on the appraised value, plus closing costs. Whether the seller has a reason to agree depends on whether the next buyer's lender is likely to see the same value, and on what your contract lets you do if they refuse.
Cover the gap in cash
Keep the price and bring the difference yourself. The math: cash to close = the contract price − the loan on the appraised value, plus closing costs. Your cash in rises by the loan-to-value share of the gap, and you own the property at a price above the value the appraisal concluded. That matters if you plan to refinance or sell within a short time, because the next appraisal is likely to draw on similar sales.
Split the gap
Meet the seller partway. The price drops by part of the gap, and you bring cash for the rest. The math sits between the two options above: the loan is still sized from the appraised value, so every dollar of price the seller gives up is a dollar less of your cash.
Request a reconsideration of value
If the appraisal missed a better-matched sale or got a fact wrong, you can ask for a second look. The request generally goes through your lender rather than to the appraiser directly, and the process, what it accepts, and how long it runs are set by your lender. It asks for evidence rather than cash, but it spends time against your contract's deadlines, and it may return the same value. Plan the other options so they still work if it does.
Change the exit
A low appraisal is information about value. If the gap came from an optimistic price rather than from a mistake in the report, rerun the deal at the appraised value on every exit you run. A purchase that fails as a rental at that value may still work as a flip, or the other way round, and one that fails on every exit is a deal to leave. If the new exit needs different financing, that is a new loan decision with its own appraisal.
Walk away under the contract's terms
Many purchase contracts include an appraisal contingency that lets the buyer renegotiate or cancel if the appraisal comes in below the price. Whether yours has one, what it requires, when it expires, and whether your deposit comes back are set by your contract; confirm with your agent or a local real estate attorney before relying on it. Walking loses what you have already spent on the deal and keeps the rest of your cash for the next one.
An illustrative purchase, worked through
Every figure below is hypothetical, chosen to make the math easy to follow, and is not a benchmark for any market, lender, or contract. The same rent, expenses, reserve, loan rate, loan term, and closing costs apply in every option, so the options differ solely in how the gap is handled.
- Contract price: $286,400
- Appraised value: $271,900, so the gap is $286,400 − $271,900 = $14,500
- Lender term (hypothetical): a loan of 75% of the lower of price and appraised value, over 30 years at 7.35%; confirm yours
- Planned loan: 75% × $286,400 = $214,800, a payment of $1,479.91 a month, or $17,758.92 a year
- Loan on the appraised value: 75% × $271,900 = $203,925, a payment of $1,404.99 a month, or $16,859.88 a year
- Closing costs: $7,318 in every option, held constant so they do not move the comparison
- Rent: $2,715 a month, or $32,580 a year
Income before debt service. Vacancy at an assumed 6% takes $1,954.80, leaving $30,625.20. Operating expenses of $8,947 leave a net operating income of $21,678.20. A capital reserve of $1,365 comes out next, leaving $20,313.20 before debt service.
The plan before the appraisal. Cash to close was $286,400 − $214,800 = $71,600, plus $7,318, for $78,918 in. Cash flow was $20,313.20 − $17,758.92 = $2,554.28 a year, a cash-on-cash return of $2,554.28 ÷ $78,918 = 3.24%.
Option one: cover the gap. The price stays at $286,400 and the loan drops to $203,925, so cash to close is $286,400 − $203,925 = $82,475, plus $7,318, for $89,793 in. That is $89,793 − $78,918 = $10,875 more than planned, which is 75% of the $14,500 gap. Debt service falls to $16,859.88, so cash flow is $20,313.20 − $16,859.88 = $3,453.32 a year, a cash-on-cash return of $3,453.32 ÷ $89,793 = 3.85%. You also start $14,500 above the appraised value.
Option two: renegotiate to the appraised value. The price falls to $271,900 and the loan is $203,925, so cash to close is $271,900 − $203,925 = $67,975, plus $7,318, for $75,293 in, which is $78,918 − $75,293 = $3,625 less than planned. Cash flow is the same $3,453.32, because the loan is the same, and the cash-on-cash return is $3,453.32 ÷ $75,293 = 4.59%. You start at the appraised value, with no gap.
Option three: split the gap. The seller gives up half of it, $14,500 ÷ 2 = $7,250, so the price is $286,400 − $7,250 = $279,150. The loan is still sized from the appraised value at $203,925, so cash to close is $279,150 − $203,925 = $75,225, plus $7,318, for $82,543 in. Cash flow is again $3,453.32, and the cash-on-cash return is $3,453.32 ÷ $82,543 = 4.18%. You start $279,150 − $271,900 = $7,250 above the appraised value.
Option four: request a reconsideration. No figure changes while the lender's process runs. When it ends, rerun options one to three at the value the lender gives you, with less time on the contract's clock.
Option five: change the exit. Rerun the deal on each exit you run, with $271,900 as the value, not $286,400. The cash and return figures are then the new exit's own.
Option six: walk. If the contract's terms allow it, you keep the rest of the $78,918 you planned to put in and lose what you have already spent on the deal. Whether any deposit comes back is set by your contract.
How to decide. Among options one to three, renegotiating leads on every measure here: the least cash in, $75,293; the highest cash-on-cash return, 4.59%; and no gap. Covering the gap puts $89,793 − $75,293 = $14,500 more of your cash into the same property for the same cash flow. Covering it also shows a higher cash-on-cash return than the plan, 3.85% against 3.24%, for one reason: each borrowed dollar costs $17,758.92 ÷ $214,800 = 8.27% a year in payments, more than the 3.24% the plan earns on your cash, so swapping borrowed dollars for your own lifts the ratio. With a cheaper loan the effect can reverse, and it is not a reason to prefer a gap. If the seller will not move, the question is whether 3.85% on $89,793 clears the return you require. If it does not, the choice is between another exit and the contract's terms.
What a reconsideration request needs
This is not a full comping exercise. The comp set post covers how appraisers select and adjust comparable sales, and the ARV walkthrough builds an after-repair value from renovated sold comps step by step. A reconsideration request needs a narrower set of things:
- Factual errors in the report. A wrong living area, bedroom or bathroom count, lot, or condition is the cleanest ground, because it can be shown rather than argued.
- Closed sales, not listings. Asking prices are not evidence of what buyers paid. Your lender may not accept sales that closed after the appraisal's effective date, because they were not available to the appraiser.
- Better-matched sales than the ones used. A sale closer to the subject in location, size, and condition than one the appraiser relied on, with a one-line reason it matches better.
- A short list. A few strong sales tend to carry more weight than many loose ones, and your lender may limit how many it will forward.
Keep the request factual and specific, send it through the lender in the form it asks for, and plan for the answer to be the same value.
When a refinance or BRRRR cash-out comes in short
On a refinance, there is no seller to renegotiate with. The new loan is the appraised value times the lender's maximum loan-to-value, a lender term (confirm yours), so a shortfall in value reduces the loan by that fraction of the missing value. The BRRRR post sizes the refinance the same way and treats the capital left in the deal as the number to watch; a low appraisal raises it. The options:
- Leave more capital in. Take the smaller loan. The math: capital left in = total cash in − cash returned at the refinance. Then check that the property still cash flows on the new loan, with the capital reserve taken after net operating income, and that the capital left in earns the return you require.
- Bring cash to close. If the smaller loan does not cover the payoff of the existing loan and the refinance's own costs, the refinance closes only if you fund the difference. The math: cash needed = existing payoff + refinance costs − the new loan.
- Request a reconsideration. The same process as on a purchase, set by your lender, built from the same kind of evidence.
- Keep the existing financing. A refinance is not a contract to buy. If no version of the new loan works, you can decline it and stay on the loan you have while its terms allow, which on short-term financing means before its maturity date.
- Change the exit. If the refinance cannot return enough capital to make the hold worth it, compare selling against holding with the capital left in. A BRRRR that does not recycle its capital is a buy-and-hold with more cash in than planned, and it should be judged as one.
The deciding figure is the capital left in and what it earns: divide the cash flow on the new loan by the capital left in, and compare that with the return you require and with what the same capital would earn in your next deal.
When your buyer's appraisal comes in low
On a flip, or on a novation where the seller's house is sold to a retail buyer, the buyer's lender appraises the house, and a low value leaves your buyer short. The options mirror the purchase side, seen from the other side of the table:
- Cut the price to the appraised value, or part of the way. Your net proceeds fall by the cut, less the sell-side charges that scale with price.
- Ask the buyer to cover the gap in cash. Whether they can depends on their cash, and if they do, your net proceeds stay where they were.
- Split the gap. Your net proceeds fall by your share of the gap, less the charges that scale with price.
- Support a reconsideration request. The request is the buyer's to make through their lender, and the process is set by that lender. You or your agent can hand the buyer's side the closed sales that support the price.
- Change the exit. If the buyer cannot close, you are back to the listing, with the appraisal as a signal about the price. The backup exit post compares a price cut, waiting, renting, a structured sale, and a discounted sale on net proceeds after carry.
- Let the buyer walk. If the buyer's contract has an appraisal contingency, they may be able to cancel; its terms are set by the contract, so confirm with your agent or a local real estate attorney.
On a novation, how a lower sale price is shared between you and the seller is set by your agreement with the seller; confirm with a local real estate attorney. If the seller's net is fixed in that agreement, every dollar of price cut comes out of your spread, less the charges that scale with price. Either way, compare the net from accepting the appraised value against the net from each other exit after the carry it takes to reach it.
A low appraisal leaves the price you agreed to where it was and moves the loan a lender will size from it. Choose between the options by the cash each one puts in and the return it leaves, not by the price you had in mind.
Where Appraize fits
Before you respond to a low appraisal, rerun the deal at the appraised value. Appraize pulls real MLS and public records data to generate comps and shows the comps behind each valuation, so you can see which sales support a price and which do not. It models all eight exit strategies for each property you analyze; on paid plans, every exit is shown side by side, so you can see whether the deal still works at the appraised value and on which exit.
The short version
A low appraisal shrinks the loan, not the price. On a purchase, price every option from the same figures: renegotiate, cover the gap, split it, request a reconsideration, change the exit, or walk under the contract's terms. On a refinance, the question is the capital left in and what it earns. On your own resale, compare the net from accepting the appraised value with the net from every other exit after carry. And if you request a reconsideration, bring closed, better-matched sales, and plan for the answer to stay the same.
Rerun your next deal at its appraised value in Appraize.