Rent is an input you have to earn
Every return figure on a rental starts with one number: what the property will actually rent for. Cash flow, cash-on-cash, cap rate, and the refinance math on a BRRRR all sit on top of it. Yet rent is the input that is easiest to accept from someone else, whether a seller's pro forma, a listing remark, or a figure somebody quoted you. This post is about earning that number yourself, the way you would earn a sale price: from comparables, adjusted, and weighted by how good the evidence is.
The rental cash flow post walks the stack from gross rent down to cash flow. This one is about the top line of that stack, and how to make it a number you can defend before you buy.
Choose rent comparables the way you would choose sale comps
A rent comparable is a unit a tenant chose instead of yours, or would have. The discipline for selecting them is the one the comp set post lays out for sales: proximity, recency, and similarity of the basics, with a small tight set beating a large loose one. Three screens do the work.
Same bedroom and bathroom count
Tenants shop by bedroom count first, then bathrooms. A three-bedroom competes with three-bedrooms; a two-bedroom of similar size is a different product with a different tenant pool. Match both counts where you can, and treat a bathroom difference as something to adjust for.
Similar size and condition
Within the same bedroom count, square footage and condition set the rent. A renovated unit and a dated one with the same floor plan rent for different amounts, and tenants see the difference in the photos before they call. Screen for the condition your property will be in on the day it lists, not the condition it is in today.
Same location, tightly defined
Rents change across a main road, a school boundary, or the line between a walkable block and one that is not. Physical distance understates those differences. Keep comparables inside the same neighborhood and, where the market is dense enough, the same few blocks or building type.
Adjust the comps toward the subject
No comparable matches perfectly, so each one gets adjusted toward your property: if the comp has something yours lacks, subtract what tenants pay for it; if yours has something the comp lacks, add it. The adjustment values come from the market itself, by finding two otherwise-similar rentals that differ in one feature and reading the gap. Garage, extra bathroom, in-unit laundry, updated kitchen, yard, and included utilities are the features to check. Keep adjustments small and few; a comp that needs large ones was not a good comp.
Signed leases outrank asking rents
An asking rent is what a landlord hoped for. A signed lease is what a tenant agreed to pay. The two can differ by a lot, and the gap can widen when a market softens, because landlords often give ground through concessions or a longer vacancy rather than by cutting the asking rent. Whenever you can get signed-lease figures, from local property managers, from the seller's own leases, or from signed-lease records where you can get them, weight those above listings. Use rental listings for what they are good for: a live read on the competition your unit will face, and a ceiling the market may or may not confirm.
Read how long comparable units sat
Days on market is a rent signal in disguise. A comparable that leased in a week at its asking rent may have been priced at or under the market; one that sat two months and then took a reduction was priced over it. Note how long each listing has been up and whether the price moved. Several similar units sitting unrented at the same rent tells you that rent is not real, no matter how many listings show it.
If the property is occupied, read the lease
An in-place lease is real evidence, but it is evidence about one tenant on one date. Read the rent, the term, the start date, any concessions, and whether the tenant is current. A rent well below your comps may be a long-tenured tenant whose rent was not raised; you inherit it until the lease, and any local rent rules, allow a change, and the increase may cost you a turnover. A rent well above your comps may be a lease that will not renew at that figure. Underwrite at the market rent your comps support and treat the existing lease as a timing question.
The worked example
All figures below are illustrative round numbers chosen to make the method easy to follow, not a benchmark for any market. The subject is a three-bedroom, two-bath single-family house of 1,400 square feet, in updated condition when it lists. Four comparables in the same neighborhood:
- Comp A: 3 bed, 2 bath, 1,400 square feet, updated. Signed lease at $1,850 two months ago, after 12 days on market.
- Comp B: 3 bed, 2 bath, 1,300 square feet, dated kitchen. Signed lease at $1,700 four months ago, after 30 days on market.
- Comp C: 3 bed, 2.5 bath, 1,500 square feet, renovated, with a garage. Asking $2,050, listed 45 days and still available.
- Comp D: 3 bed, 1 bath, 1,400 square feet, updated. Signed lease at $1,725 six months ago, after 18 days on market.
Assumed adjustment values, drawn from paired rentals in this hypothetical market: $25 per 100 square feet, $100 for updated versus dated condition, $75 for a full bathroom, $50 for a half bath, and $50 for a garage.
- Comp A adjusted: no differences, stays at $1,850
- Comp B adjusted: $1,700 + $25 (100 square feet smaller) + $100 (dated condition) = $1,825
- Comp C adjusted: $2,050 − $25 (100 square feet larger) − $50 (half bath) − $50 (garage) = $1,925, but this is an asking rent that has not found a tenant in 45 days
- Comp D adjusted: $1,725 + $75 (one fewer bathroom) = $1,800, but six months old
The three signed leases, adjusted, land at $1,800, $1,825, and $1,850, with the freshest and closest match at the top of that cluster. The asking comp at $1,925 is not evidence of what tenants pay; its 45 days without a tenant is evidence that they are not paying it. A defensible range for the subject is $1,800 to $1,850. Underwrite at $1,800 and run the deal again at $1,700 to see what a soft leasing season does to it.
Why an overstated rent breaks everything downstream
Rent is the line every other line depends on. Vacancy and management are percentages of it. Net operating income is what is left of it. Cash flow is what is left of that after the capital reserve and the loan. So an error in rent does not shrink as it moves down the stack; it lands almost whole on a cash flow figure that is a small remainder of a large number. In the rental cash flow post's worked example, a $2,000 rent produced $200 a month of cash flow; overstating that rent by $100 would have cut the cash flow by more than 40 percent.
Cap rate and cash-on-cash both move with the rent, so a rent that is $100 too high makes a property look like it clears your minimum when it does not. On a BRRRR, the BRRRR calculator post ties post-rehab rental income to whether the refinance works at all, which turns an overstated rent into a deal that cannot exit rather than one that merely underperforms. And if you are buying in a market you do not live in, the market selection post covers the demand side, jobs and wages and population, that decides whether the rent your comps support will still be there in a few years.
A rent you were told is a hope. A rent you built from signed leases, adjusted and discounted for how long the comps sat, is a number you can put money behind.
The short version
Pick a few rentals that match on bedrooms, bathrooms, size, condition, and block. Adjust each toward your property with values the market gave you. Weight signed leases over asking rents, and read how long each comparable sat. If the house is occupied, treat the lease as a timing question, not the market rent. Underwrite at the low end of the range you can defend, stress it lower, and only then start the cash flow math.